Moderator: Puja
At a guess, I'd suggest PRL rules on playing outsidde of IRB9.Raggs wrote:Withdrawn by Sale seems a bit odd?
Nah, Baabaas is a spectacle, not international release. Plenty of PRL players have played baabaas in this game before, I'm sure.Which Tyler wrote:At a guess, I'd suggest PRL rules on playing outsidde of IRB9.Raggs wrote:Withdrawn by Sale seems a bit odd?
Possibly the Newcastle pair to do likewise; possibly Newcastle preferring to take their £60k fine and keep the players happy - although they're both lat additions, so that might get them through.
ETA: If that was the casem, surely McGinty would sit out, but stay with the squad?
If that's the case, then withdraw injuredDigby wrote:Mark Reagan played a BaaBaas game when his club could have used him, and that drew censure. Blocking players when they clubs don't have games is a little different, but if he has a niggle that could turn into worse then for me the club are just being professional.
I find it hard to think we should be worried about IRB9 when there's a game Vs us at HQ
They're technically entitled to do it - it's outside the international release days and they could be wanting to restrict his risk of injury. However, it appears to be another dick move from a club that's becoming increasingly hard to like.Raggs wrote: Bad News - Withdrawals
Aki / Piutau (Injured)
MacGinty withdrawn by Sale
-------
Withdrawn by Sale seems a bit odd?
Totes. But preaching to the choir. Sounds like quite a few of us are getting seriously pissed off with Eddie. As predicted by the SH posters.Banquo wrote:thisfivepointer wrote:Smith's retention just really irritates me. He's been named in the U20 squad and thats where he should be. There's no point naming him unless he isnt going to be a key member of the team out in France.
For all his undoubted talent, he is not going to make the RWC.
far better to concentrate on people who might. Which brings me to my next irritation: Cips named as a full back. This is just f******* stupid. Over the season Cips has been by far the best FH in England. He needs to play in his proper position to make a case for longer term selection. Eddie could easily have named him as an "inside back" and used him as a ready made club half back pairing with Robson, who is set to play some part. Youngs and Ford to start with Cips and Robson on the bench. What is there not to like about that option?
If Cips covers 15, he could easily be the 3rd 10 in the squad. Ford is a 10 only, Farrell covers 10/12, having Cips to cover 10/15 would be handy. If it works, the FBs will be Brown and Watson, mind.Digby wrote:If Cipriani can cover 15 he makes naming a RWC squad much, much easier. Okay it makes a mockery of certain other claims Eddie has made, but I can quite see why he wants to see if some players can offer him multiple options
Agree, but it should be cleared with the employer first, before the invitation is annouced so that there is not all this chopping and changing. It is still something of an honour to play for the Barbarians. Imagine what it means to a player like McGinty to be selected, only to find that your club will then not let you play. I know the game is all hard nosed professional now, there are injury worries etc.., but at this stage of the season Sale has nothing to play for. Would it have hurt to allow the lad a run and a great rugby experience?Peej wrote:Does the BaaBaas count as an international if it doesn't award caps? So is this a loophole to get around IRB9?
It's an invitational side, so whoever receives that invitation presumably needs to clear it with their employer.
N.B: As a Wasps fan, the irony of talking about invitations and accepting them or not after the furore caused by a soon-to-be-ex player this past week is not lost on me
Sale announced his selection on their website and social media before pulling him. It’s all very strange.Spiffy wrote:Agree, but it should be cleared with the employer first, before the invitation is annouced so that there is not all this chopping and changing. It is still something of an honour to play for the Barbarians. Imagine what it means to a player like McGinty to be selected, only to find that your club will then not let you play. I know the game is all hard nosed professional now, there are injury worries etc.., but at this stage of the season Sale has nothing to play for. Would it have hurt to allow the lad a run and a great rugby experience?Peej wrote:Does the BaaBaas count as an international if it doesn't award caps? So is this a loophole to get around IRB9?
It's an invitational side, so whoever receives that invitation presumably needs to clear it with their employer.
N.B: As a Wasps fan, the irony of talking about invitations and accepting them or not after the furore caused by a soon-to-be-ex player this past week is not lost on me
What are they supposed to say? If they say AJ MacGinty has withdrawn, it makes out he did it himself. If it's the truth, say it. They've not added reasons etc, which may have made a difference either way.Peej wrote:That can only be it. Otherwise it's just looks petty on behalf of Sale. Seems a bit of a jibe from the BaaBaas though to say specifically that he was withdrawn by the club.