Page 2 of 5
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 11:54 am
by Banquo
Puja wrote:I can't see how that's harsh. It's a shoulder charge with force, which is a yellow even before it's contact direct to the head. You could argue that he's unlucky that he's hit the head, but you could also argue that that's his own problem for throwing his shoulder into a challenge.
Massive opportunity for Australia here. If they can't win from this position, they may as well stop playing New Zealand.
Puja
Harsh red for me. Real time had no time to react to Hooper being spun round by Coles, and initial contact wasn't with shoulder imo. Greenwood has it right- you could red card almost every breakdown. If there is any argument, as you posit, then it is harsh.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 11:56 am
by Banquo
White actually looks a good 9 in this.
Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:01 pm
by Spy
Great try. Lomu-esque.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:02 pm
by Eugene Wrayburn
Spy wrote:Is that what a red card is these days? Pretty tough. Only the fourth AB red card in history. Probably not in the top 4 bad AB tackles in history.
That very much is what a red card is these days. Forceful contact with the head in a shoulder with no attempt to make a valid tackle or validly hit the ruck. It is textbook under the current provisions and Garces was right to say he had no choice.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:13 pm
by 16th man
Spy wrote:Is that what a red card is these days? Pretty tough. Only the fourth AB red card in history. Probably not in the top 4 bad AB tackles in history.
Says a lot about historic reffing of the ABs, less about what should be a red.
Hansen will bitch about it, in the same way he thought SBW should only have been yellowed for his shot on Watson.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:19 pm
by Banquo
14 men or otherwise AB's have been struggling to contain the wobblies attack all game.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:22 pm
by Spy
16th man wrote:
Says a lot about historic reffing of the ABs, less about what should be a red.
Hansen will bitch about it, in the same way he thought SBW should only have been yellowed for his shot on Watson.
In reality, it speaks more to how these things were refereed historically generally, and how it has changed in recent years. Not necessarily for the worse.
There was no question about the sbw red, IMO. Will need to see this one again.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:22 pm
by Spy
Banquo wrote:14 men or otherwise AB's have been struggling to contain the wobblies attack all game.
Yep.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:26 pm
by Banquo
Spy wrote:Banquo wrote:14 men or otherwise AB's have been struggling to contain the wobblies attack all game.
Yep.
Very nice stuff from the wallabies, lots of variety.
This must be getting close to a record stuffing as it stands?
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:29 pm
by Eugene Wrayburn
Banquo wrote:White actually looks a good 9 in this.
Has a lot to do with a pack getting at least parity.
I reckon the Wallabies might have taken this anyway without the red. Looking quite useful as they were always likely to by the time of the RWC.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:31 pm
by Eugene Wrayburn
And what has happened to Rieko Ioane? He's been awfully quiet of late.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:31 pm
by Puja
Wallabies got a little bit of luck - the Koroibete try from close range shouldn't have stood, as he wasn't the back man. But having said that, the Kiwi second try was clearly forward and Garces has had a very funny idea of what constitutes a knock on all game, so it's evened out.
Puja
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:32 pm
by Puja
Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Banquo wrote:White actually looks a good 9 in this.
Has a lot to do with a pack getting at least parity.
Cause he doesn't normally get that at Exeter?
Puja
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:34 pm
by Banquo
Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Banquo wrote:White actually looks a good 9 in this.
Has a lot to do with a pack getting at least parity.
I
reckon the Wallabies might have taken this anyway without the red. Looking quite useful as they were always likely to by the time of the RWC.
Agreed, as per my previous statement. Pack have had better than parity- possession and territory stats are quite stunning.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:35 pm
by Banquo
Puja wrote:Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Banquo wrote:White actually looks a good 9 in this.
Has a lot to do with a pack getting at least parity.
Cause he doesn't normally get that at Exeter?
Puja
well quite
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:35 pm
by Eugene Wrayburn
Puja wrote:Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Banquo wrote:White actually looks a good 9 in this.
Has a lot to do with a pack getting at least parity.
Cause he doesn't normally get that at Exeter?
Puja
I watch zero Premiership rugby. From what I've seen the scrum half at exeter is required to do little more than pass to the next bloke to maintain possession.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:36 pm
by Banquo
Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Puja wrote:Eugene Wrayburn wrote:
Has a lot to do with a pack getting at least parity.
Cause he doesn't normally get that at Exeter?
Puja
I watch
zero Premiership rugby. From what I've seen the scrum half at exeter is required to do little more than pass to the next bloke to maintain possession.
eh?
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:37 pm
by Eugene Wrayburn
Banquo wrote:Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Puja wrote:
Cause he doesn't normally get that at Exeter?
Puja
I watch
zero Premiership rugby. From what I've seen the scrum half at exeter is required to do little more than pass to the next bloke to maintain possession.
eh?
They do play in another competition, albeit not usually for very long.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:40 pm
by Spy
Sound thrashing. Australia were considerably the better team all over. The two tries right after the break pretty much sealed it. Although there was plenty of rugby played after that, the All Blacks inability to hold their line at that point was critical. Well played Oz.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:42 pm
by Banquo
Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Banquo wrote:Eugene Wrayburn wrote:
I watch zero Premiership rugby. From what I've seen the scrum half at exeter is required to do little more than pass to the next bloke to maintain possession.
eh?
They do play in another competition, albeit not usually for very long.
So you would have seen he's looked very average for Chiefs- even accepting your critique of Chiefs play.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:46 pm
by Eugene Wrayburn
Banquo wrote:Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Banquo wrote:
eh?
They do play in another competition, albeit not usually for very long.
So you would have seen he's looked very average for Chiefs- even accepting your critique of Chiefs play.
My point is that it's a game plan that calls for the very average.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:46 pm
by Banquo
Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Banquo wrote:Eugene Wrayburn wrote:
They do play in another competition, albeit not usually for very long.
So you would have seen he's looked very average for Chiefs- even accepting your critique of Chiefs play.
My point is that it's a game plan that calls for the very average.
well he even manages to be poor at that, again allowing for your dismissal of their game plan.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:50 pm
by Eugene Wrayburn
Spy wrote:Sound thrashing. Australia were considerably the better team all over. The two tries right after the break pretty much sealed it. Although there was plenty of rugby played after that, the All Blacks inability to hold their line at that point was critical. Well played Oz.
Aye. Interestingly not much attacking pizzazz in these ABs currently which makes me think there might be a bit being held back.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 12:52 pm
by Eugene Wrayburn
Banquo wrote:Eugene Wrayburn wrote:Banquo wrote:
So you would have seen he's looked very average for Chiefs- even accepting your critique of Chiefs play.
My point is that it's a game plan that calls for the very average.
well he even manages to be poor at that, again allowing for your dismissal of their game plan.
He just looked ordinary to me. Or very average, to use a phrase.
Re: Australia v. New Zealand is going to be quite a FORCE-ful encounter or something, fuck it, you do the jokes.
Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2019 1:05 pm
by paddy no 11
Looking back its a clear red - the shoulder is dropped when he's 2 or 3 yards away the arm was never out